By allowing ads to appear on this site, you support the local businesses who, in turn, support great journalism.
Crawford: State cuts off its nose to spite its face
Placeholder Image

I was taught at a young age that you shouldn’t cut off your nose to spite your face.

In other words, don’t engage in destructive action just because you’re angry at someone, because you usually end up hurting yourself more than the other person.

I wish our elected leadership had remembered that lesson during their consideration of whether the state should accept billions of dollars from the federal government to expand the Medicaid health insurance program and make coverage available to more low-income families.

This expansion of Medicaid is a key provision of the Affordable Care Act, known more familiarly to consumers as Obamacare.

The law provides that for three years, beginning in 2014, the federal government must pay 100 percent of a state’s costs of expanding Medicaid so that more people who can’t afford insurance will have access to medical care.

After that three-year period, the federal government is required to continue paying 90 percent of the costs associated with expanded Medicaid, while the state picks up the other 10 percent.

States can choose whether to accept that federal money or not. If Gov. Nathan Deal had said yes to the offer, it would have resulted in more than $3 billion in federal funds flowing into Georgia this year for payment to the doctors and hospitals that treat Medicaid patients.

Deal has refused to accept this money to expand Medicaid coverage, even though such health care groups as the Medical Association of Georgia and the Georgia Hospital Association support expansion.

The governor recently signed a bill transferring the authority for that decision from his office to the General Assembly, which means the state likely will never take the money.

Other governors have accepted the federal funds, including such Republican chief executives as Rick Snyder of Michigan, Jan Brewer of Arizona, Chris Christie of New Jersey and Terry Branstad of Iowa.

When Snyder signed the “Healthy Michigan” legislation for Medicaid expansion, he said, “The federal funds for Healthy Michigan are part of the Affordable Care Act. Many have strong feelings about this law and I don’t think it’s the right answer in many respects. However, it is the law of the land and it will be implemented.”

Brewer had to browbeat a Republican-controlled legislature to get approval for using the federal health care funds in Arizona, but after she succeeded she remarked, “It was a win, win, win all the way around.”

When Christie made the decision to accept Obamacare money for New Jersey, he said, “We are putting people first. Which is why, after considerable discussion and research, I have decided to participate in the Medicaid expansion under the Affordable Care Act.”

Deal and the legislative leadership in Georgia have taken the opposite course, and I think a large factor in their decision was political spite toward a Democratic president. What better way to express that spite than to slap the hand offering you billions of dollars in federal money?

There is always a price to pay for this kind of behavior, as it turns out.

The widespread media coverage of the Obamacare implementation has prompted thousands of people to step forward to sign up for Medicaid coverage. In many cases, these are people who were already eligible for coverage but were not aware of it — so they will have access to health care even if their state does not accept federal funds for Medicaid expansion.

Health care experts call this the “woodwork effect,” because these people have figuratively come out of the woodwork to sign up for coverage.

A study released last week indicates that nearly 100,000 people in Georgia who had been eligible for Medicaid coverage all along signed up for the program as Obamacare was being rolled out in recent months. It is estimated these new enrollees will cost the state about $90 million in additional yearly Medicaid expenses.

That is where our leadership has put us. The state refuses to accept more than $3 billion in federal funds for Medicaid expansion, but it is on the hook to pay another $90 million in Medicaid costs anyway.

That doesn’t sound like a smart deal to me, but that’s what happens when your decisions are influenced by political spite instead of logic and reasoning.

Tom Crawford is editor of The Georgia Report. His column appears Wednesdays and at

Regional events