By allowing ads to appear on this site, you support the local businesses who, in turn, support great journalism.
Health care bill clears Senate
Georgias senators call legislation flawed
Placeholder Image

Both Georgia’s Republican senators have promised to continue to fight Democrat-led health care reform after the U.S. Senate voted Thursday morning to approve its health care bill.

The bill could define President Barack Obama’s legacy and usher in near-universal medical coverage for the first time in the country’s history.

The Senate passed the bill on Christmas Eve morning in a 60-39 vote, with both Georgia’s Sen. Johnny Isakson and Sen. Saxby Chambliss voting against it.

The two promised their votes would stay the same as the House and the Senate hash out a compromise between the two different versions of the bill.

The two chambers must reach a compromise on a final health care reform bill and both must vote to approve that compromise before a final bill is sent to the president.

Chambliss, in a statement released by his office, said the bill was created behind closed doors and did not represent meaningful reform.

“Americans are right do demand access to affordable health care. But the Senate bill is bad legislation,” Chambliss said. “It is a political victory — not a substantive one — that will actually make health care more expensive.”

In a statement released by his office Thursday, Isakson called the latest Senate version a “terribly flawed” bill that will cut benefits for seniors, raise taxes and insurance premiums. He said the bill was an unfunded mandate that would bankrupt state governments.

And Gov. Sonny Perdue on Wednesday asked that Attorney General Thurbert Baker join the seven other attorneys general, all Republicans, who say they are looking into allegations of special deals made by Senate leadership to sway wavering senators.

“The leadership of Congress, particularly Senate leadership, understands the financial devastation that is looming for states, which is clearly evidenced by the special deals that have been cut for states that have Democratic senators with wavering support of the reform,” Perdue wrote to Baker. “In order to calm the concerns, Senate leadership has granted special exemptions with additional federal dollars to cover the substantial increases in Medicaid costs for a few states while leaving the rest of us to foot the entire bill.”

A spokesman for Baker said Wednesday his office hasn’t yet received any correspondence from the governor.

“But it does seem problematic to launch a legal review of legislation that is still being amended in the legislative process and has not yet been enacted,” Russ Willard said.

Baker is seeking the Democratic nomination for governor.

After Thursday morning’s vote, Democrats praised the bill.

“We are now finally poised to deliver on the promise of real, meaningful health insurance reform that will bring additional security and stability to the American people,” Obama said shortly after the Senate acted.

“This will be the most important piece of social legislation since Social Security passed in the 1930s,” said Obama, standing with Vice President Joe Biden in the State Room of the White House.

The 60-39 vote on a cold winter morning capped months of arduous negotiations and 24 days of floor debate. It also followed a succession of failures by past Congresses to get to this point. Biden presided as 58 Democrats and two independents voted “yes.” Republicans unanimously voted “no.”

An exhausted Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., initially cast a “no” vote by mistake, then quickly corrected himself as fellow senators burst out laughing.

The tally far exceeded the simple majority required for passage.

The Senate’s bill must still be merged with legislation passed by the House before Obama could sign a final bill in the new year. There are significant differences between the two measures but Democrats say they’ve come too far now to fail.

Both bills would extend health insurance to more than 30 million more Americans. Obama said the legislation “includes the toughest measures ever taken to hold the insurance industry accountable.”

Vicki Kennedy, the widow of Sen. Edward M. Kennedy, D-Mass., who made health care reform his life’s work, watched the vote from the gallery. So did Rep. John Dingell, D-Mich., the longest-serving House member and a champion of universal health care his entire career.

“This morning isn’t the end of the process, it’s merely the beginning. We’ll continue to build on this success to improve our health system even more,” Reid said before the vote. “But that process cannot begin unless we start today ... there may not be a next time.”

At a news conference a few moments later, Reid said the vote “brings us one step closer to making Ted Kennedy’s dream a reality.”
The Nevadan said “every step of this long process has been an enormous undertaking.”

Sen. Max Baucus, D-Mont., chairman of the Finance Committee, said he was “very happy to see people getting health care they could not get.”

It was the Senate’s first Christmas Eve vote since 1895, when the matter at hand was a military affairs bill concerning employment of former Confederate officers, according to the Senate Historical Office.

After the vote, Obama offered congratulations in phone calls to Vicki Kennedy and Reid, Baucus and other senators, including 92-year-old Robert Byrd, D-W.Va., who was brought to the Senate in a wheelchair.

The House passed its own measure in November. The White House and Congress have now come further toward the goal of a comprehensive overhaul of the nation’s health care system than any of their predecessors.

The legislation would ban the insurance industry from denying benefits or charging higher premiums on the basis of pre-existing medical conditions. The Congressional Budget Office predicts the bill will reduce deficits by $130 billion over the next 10 years, an estimate that assumes lawmakers carry through on hundreds of billions of dollars in planned cuts to insurance companies and doctors, hospitals and others who treat Medicare patients.

For the first time, the government would require nearly every American to carry insurance, and subsidies would be provided to help low-income people to do so. Employers would be induced to cover their employees through a combination of tax credits and penalties. The legislation costs nearly $1 trillion over 10 years and is paid for by a combination of taxes, fees and cuts to Medicare.
Republicans were withering in their criticism of what they deemed a budget-busting government takeover. If the measure were worthwhile, contended Minority Leader Mitch McConnell, R-Ky., “they wouldn’t be rushing it through Congress on Christmas Eve.”
House Minority Leader John Boehner assailed the bill moments after passage.

“Not even Ebenezer Scrooge himself could devise a scheme as cruel and greedy as Democrats’ government takeover of health care,” the Ohio Republican said in a statement.

“Sen. Reid’s health care bill increases premiums for families and small businesses, raises taxes during a recession, cuts seniors’ Medicare benefits, adds to our skyrocketing debt and puts bureaucrats in charge of decisions that should be made by patients and doctors,” he said.

The occasion was moving for Sen. Paul Kirk, D-Mass., appointed to fill Kennedy’s seat after his death in August.

“He’s having a merry Christmas in heaven,” Kirk told reporters after the tally. He said he was “humbled to be here with the honor of casting essentially his vote.”

Said Dingell: “This is for me, this is for my dad, this is for the country.”

Reid nailed down the last votes in a rush of deal-making in the last week that is now coming under attack because of special provisions obtained by a number of senators. In Nebraska, home to conservative Democrat Ben Nelson, the Democrats’ crucial 60th vote, the federal government will pay 100 percent of the cost of a planned Medicaid expansion in perpetuity, the only state getting that deal.

Negotiations between the House and Senate to reconcile differences between the two bills are expected to begin as soon as next week. The House bill has stricter limits on abortion than the Senate, and unlike the House, the Senate measure omits a government-run insurance option, which liberals favored to apply pressure on private insurers but Democratic moderates opposed as an unwarranted federal intrusion. Obama has signaled he will sign a bill even if it lacks that provision.

Times reporter Ashley Fielding contributed to this report.

Regional events